The Case For Men’s Reading Groups
I’ve had the privilege of being invited to speak to hundreds of book clubs, usually to discuss one of my novels. I find it to be an invaluable experience for a writer. First, because I learn so much about what readers look for in fiction, and second, because I learn about my own work, both the good and the bad. Unlike paid critics, these readers read a book because they want to.
However, I’ve made two troubling observations in my experience with these groups. First, there appear to be fewer book clubs than there were in the ’90s, and each one has fewer people. When I first started being invited, the average book club had eight to twelve people. Now it’s more like five or six. These observations echo a broader decline in reading for pleasure. A recent study published in the journal iScience found that “the proportion [of people] who read for pleasure on an average day declined over the last 20 years, from highs of 28 percent in 2004 to lows of 16 percent in 2023,” a decline of some 40 percent.
The second observation is that the book groups I’ve been invited to are composed overwhelmingly of women. Data suggests as many as 88 percent of private book clubs consist of all women. Occasionally I’ll find a lone man in a group, and once I had a co-ed book group of male-female partners, but those seem to be anomalies.
